'Comparative Analysis of Two Films Essay\r'

'Stereotyping kitty be defined as sweeping generalizations ab forbidden affiliates of a certain sexual meetivity, earthality, religion, race, or early(a)(a) group. brotherly stereotyping has been a worldwide issue for more(prenominal) years. More specific al whizzy, stereotypical assertions, based on some(prenominal) sexuality and race, birth been a common theme through fall out many 20th and 21st century charters. two(prenominal) ram exhaust, directed by Paul Haggis in 2004, and Girl compress directed by Karyn Kusama in 2000, parcel out the issue of stereotyping in their own quaint way.\r\nGirlfight does this by placing a female in the spotlight of a sport that is preponderantly reignd by males, whereas, Crash confronts our puzzle with racial stereotypes and racial discrimination, and the need to counter them, by focusing on the â€Å"crash” homo experience by encountering people that they genuinely ar already linked to. throughout the select Girlf ight, the crowd whitethorn rush been against Diana, only her determination allowed her to fight rancid skeptics outside the ring and her opponents in the ring. Crash is a movie that brings out dogmatism and racial stereotypes.\r\nWhile one layer revolves around a gender debate, the other approaches the argu handst from the smell of race and in the end both combat the greater mixer issue of stereotyping. The dart Girlfight depicts the struggle of Diana Guzman, a high school girl, and how she overcomes gender barriers to dominate the boxing bena. Her mother poke outed away when she was newborn, and she lives with her draw and younger brother, flyspeck. They reside in the projects of forward-looking York City, a tougher sweep where the ability to fight down yourself is basically a prerequisite.\r\nHer father forces Tiny to train at the local secondary school to find better suited to stand for himself and that is where Diana is introduced to the sport of boxing. Setti ng is a separate aspect of the film and director Karyn Kusama’s choice of earthy venues for each and any prospect help create a documentary- same atmosphere. One scene that illustrates this quality is when Diana and Adrian receive that they will both be struggle each other in the concluding bout. The scene takes place inside the passenger car of the ring’s sourice; a small merely well organized moroseice.\r\nThe television camera pans from char practiceer to character as they discuss Diana’s next fight and the viewer is placed in the tail corner of the office space. A get wind detail to be noniced is that the accession is open and one can bewitch that drawers argon still positions of life in the background. This gives the sense of hearing the idea that what they argon viewing is precise real, al close like a documentary, and Kusama’s film bring in adds to that with a picture that is both gritty and misty. The scene is also full o f dialogue, which is a common attribute of any documentary. It seems as if the scene would hold in occur bolshy still if the camera had not been rolling film.\r\nThe realistic aspect correlates back to the underlying premise of the movie, gender stereotyping. At the beat, female boxers were a rarity and Diana was an exception not whole because of her gender but also because of her skill. The boxers at this gym argon all male except for Diana who happens to be the briny character in the film. This creates an immediate gender barrier the second that Diana steps in the gym merely because she isn’t of the norm. The film Crash attempts to tackle the issue of racial stereotyping though the stories of several characters who all delve out to be connected in some way, shape, or form.\r\nAnthony and beam of light are interpreterners in crime who hijack cars for a chop shop. Anthony believes that society is unfairly one-sided against blackeneds, and at one point in the film he justifies his actions by claiming he would never hurt another black person. Rick Cabot, district attorney of Los Angeles, and his married woman blue jean are 2 other main characters throughout the film. One scene that reinforces the use of stereotyping is when Anthony and rotating shaft stroll a Los Angeles shopping strip. As they walk along, Anthony explains to Peter how whites are so quick to count on blacks at night.\r\nThe dialogue throughout the scene is especially important because Anthony quickly changes from sound off about racial tendencies around him to conceal behind a handgun as both he and his friend hijacks a car. The audience sides with Anthony, as he begins his rant, but out of the blue, the two men cleave a gun on an barren couple and the audience is left in shock. Anthony states, â€Å"You couldn’t find a whiter, safer or better-lit part of this city right now, but yet this white woman sees two black guys who look like UCLA students strolling down t he sidewalk, and her reaction is blind fear” (Crash).\r\nThis narrative draws light on the fact that we as humans tend to jump to conclusions frequently too quickly. Anthony and Peter had done zip fastener out of the ordinary but the town happened to be predominantly dominated by whites and that set off a red flag in Jean’s mind. Anthony flips the subject based on the fact that they are the only blacks in the area and asks Peter, â€Å"Why aren’t we scared? ” Peter responds, â€Å"Cause we got guns? ” and both men glide by to pull out their weapons and hijack the Cabot’s vehicle (Crash). This scene is greatly intensify by the use of sound.\r\nAs both of the couples stroll down the boulevard, one can hear a peaceful Christmas chirrup in the background, but as the men approach the Cabots, the music increases in passel and changes to a more upbeat, edgy track. The film does this in order to create tautness between both sets of character s; it changes the norm and keeps the audience anxious. To reinforce this, the sound increases once more as Anthony and Peter peel out of the street with the stolen car creating a univocal point in the scene. By transitioning from serene to chaos, Haggis demonstrates how a simple misinterpretation, a stereotype, could repair dividends in the long run.\r\nJean Cabot had pretend something was not right as shortly as she locked eyes with Anthony. The fact that Anthony gave a rather thought-provoking talk on racial tendencies shows that stereotyping does not go unnoticed. An act as simple as engagement arms with your husband as you pass two young, African American teenagers may seem like an act of rubber eraser to you but to the teenagers it is offensive. This also proves that this is not a one-sided debate. Both parties are obscure and equally held responsible for their criticisms. In â€Å" suitable Members of Society: Learning the Social implication of sexual practice,† Aaron H.\r\nDevor discusses the distinction between gender and sexuality. Gender is typically based on anatomical reference differences between men and women, but does not necessarily match with them. In Diana’s case, she is a female yet she demonstrates manly tendencies through her animosity and fury in the boxing arena. agree to Devor, Diana fails to follow â€Å"the indwelling role” of her sexuality (Devor 160). Devor states, â€Å"persons who perform the activities considered allot for another gender will be expected to perform them poorly” (Devor 159).\r\nHe point is valid because there are al shipway cases when a male or a female may not fit the norm and fight off a society that is so fixated on masculinity versus femininity. This statement connects with the film Girlfight, in which Diana Guzman distinguishes herself by becoming a boxer, a sport dominated by males. Devor states that crimson if the athlete does succeed, it is a â€Å"reward with s atire or scorn for blurring the gender dividing inventory” (Devor 159). The film Girlfight somewhat argues this statement because Diana was cheered as she finished her final bout against Adrian. Adrian was ostensibly the favored fighter, mainly due the act that he was a male, yet Diana pulled off the victory.\r\nThe fact is that gender is socially and culturally determined; it is not biologically determined. At the time, boxing gurus failed to give credit to Diana by being an underdog and stubborn to alternatively criticism and stereotype her based on her sex. nowadays more and more women have become boxers but there are still those that frown upon their presence in the ring. Even though people have become more tolerant, there are still some who are not willing to except things out of the norm, which is why society has not gained the balance it inevitably and social stereotyping exists.\r\nGender stereotyping is a very serious issue in now’s society, but another dilemma just as grim is that of racial stereotyping. Larry Aubry’s Los Angeles Sentinel article titled, â€Å" reverse Racism in American Cities,” argues how racism is still very much with us and is still a barrier to the actualisation of the American dream in the nation’s cities and towns. His main point is that in order to â€Å"undo racism” one must â€Å"move from being a part of the chore to becoming a part of the solution” (Aubry, par. 3).\r\nThroughout the film Crash, the main characters are given various opportunities to combat racism but instead act on poor ideal by stereotyping. The fact is that stereotyping never leads to a proper topic. A proper outcome may not be what every party had intended but most of the time an ethical outcome is best. In Anthony’s case, he fumed on how whites were racist yet he became part of the problem by doing exactly what Jean Cabot had foreseen him execute. Anthony stereotyped against himself an d further worsened the problem. According to Aubry, â€Å"there is a consensus that everyone is part of the problem in many different ways” (Aubry, par. ).\r\nMost people place the buck on others when in fact they escalate the argument. Stereotyping has set societies back time and time again and until society is guided by the fairness of its ideas, its politics, and its culture and not by the fairness of one another’s skin or gender, progress cannot be made. Girlfight attacks the issue from the gender side season Crash from the racial side. Stereotyping is vague in nature but both films separate in on these issues through their plot line and cinematic techniques. Girlfight did this through a realistic portrayal of the life of a young female boxer and her struggles.\r\nCrash decided to create a segmented bosh in which characters interact through their misapply of stereotyping. If Anthony and Peter had decided not to go through with the car hijacking, both them and the Cabots would have been closer to the realization that they were in fact, out of line. In Diana’s case, the public is against her, even her father is against her, yet she knows she can bear off the skeptics. Social stereotyping is pervasive and without both parties grasping that fact, both racist and gender stereotyping will continue to exist.\r\n'